American History Hijacked by Ideology – The Dangers and the Cure

Jeff Bridges -- The Giver -- 2014 Movie2014 movie:  Jeff Bridges is “The Giver” of historical truth in a sterilized dystopian society
(photo credit)

Intro by Jeff Rutherford

As I have lately been immersed in topics of history, I was especially interested in the most recent issue of Imprimis published by Hillsdale College.  Entitled “History, American Democracy, and the AP Test Controversy,” it’s from a speech by University of Oklahoma History Professor Wilfred M. McClay on July 10, 2015.  The full 3500-word Imprimis transcript delves deeper into the troubles hitting the field of historical research and education — as indicated by the title — including the decline in popularity of books by historians, and the recent controversial changes to the Advanced Placement U.S. History (APUSH) test, which is closely related to the conservative movement’s concerns with Common Core education mandates. Click the above link to read the entire Imprimis article.

Here, I have excerpted less than 1/3 of the transcript, sticking to the more central passages about the role the study of history plays in a free society, and the dangers we face by losing sight of Continue reading

Posted in Real Life | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Due Process of Law, #4: America’s Founding – The Capstone of the Age of Enlightenment

Declaration of Independence presented to 2nd Continental Congress 6-28-1776

1818 painting by John Trumbull
First draft of the Declaration of Independence being presented to the Second Continental Congress

By Jeff Rutherford

[Part 1 was called “Can a Law be Unlawful?”]
[Part 2 was called “What Makes a Government’s Actions Legit?”]
[Part 3 was called “Cicero and Aquinas Preserved Aristotle’s Flame”]

This series has been tracing the lineage of the concept of Due Process of Law from the dawn of the notion of individualism in ancient Greece, through the Roman Republic and Empire, the Dark Ages, the feudalism of Medieval Europe, and into Europe’s Age of Enlightenment.  Now Part 4 describes how these centuries of philosophical seeds migrated across the Atlantic and took root in the American colonies, forming the political basis for the American Revolution and influencing the structure of the American Republic.

Origins of American Constitutionalism - Donald LutzIn 1988, University of Houston political science professor Donald Lutz’ book The Origins of American Constitutionalism contained the results of a 10-year study of historic political writings during the American Founding era – 1760 to 1805.  The study identified and counted Continue reading

Posted in Theory of Gov't | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Left and Right Worldviews on the Iran Deal

Obama and NetanyahuIntro by Jeff Rutherford

Twice recently I have shown Dr. Thomas Sowell’s side-by-side comparison of the Left’s vs. Right’s conflicting instincts about how best to maintain international peace.  Continue reading

Posted in Politics in Practice, Theory of Gov't | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Rare Earth Elements: How the U.S. Shoots Itself in the Foot

The Ed - icon sizeContributed by Ed

Being an engineer, I love to talk about rare earth elements (REEs).  I can be very chatty about the magic of their F orbitals, what it means to their quantum mechanical properties, and so forth.  I have done that to my poor, long suffering wife of 38 years, and after she snaps out of her tech induced trance she quickly changes the subject to one that she knows something about.  Still, if you look around the house, rare earths abound in the Continue reading

Posted in Contributed by 'The Ed', Our Political Economy | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Due Process of Law, #3: Cicero and St. Thomas Aquinas Preserved Aristotle’s Flame

Statue in Aristotle Park StagiraStatue in Aristotle’s Park at Stagira, Greece
(photo credit)

By Jeff Rutherford

[Part 1 was called “Can a Law be Unlawful?”]
[Part 2 was called “What Makes a Government’s Actions Legit?”]

As I try to plow this field of the history of Western political and legal philosophy, learning as I go, a newfound friend and fellow originalist blogger – Keith DeHavelle – recently pointed out a rich patch of ground I missed a ways back.

In Part 2, I was short-sighted in leaping over the important contributions to the development of individualism from two men:  Roman philosopher, lawyer and orator Marcus Tullius Cicero (106-43 BC) and Italian philosopher and theologian St. Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274).  So I paused to put in some learnin’ time.

These fascinating men bridged the centuries from Continue reading

Posted in Theory of Gov't | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 11 Comments “Natural Law, Natural Allies”

Aristotle - Avoiding Criticism(graphic credit)

By Keith DeHavelle, 6/19/2015
Reblogged from

Natural Law, Natural Allies

From time to time, I mention in these writings that I am non-religious. This has always been true of me; I am not a “converted” or “lapsed” or “apostate” anything. But many of my fellow conservatives are indeed deeply religious, and sometimes express disbelief or even disdain that a non-theist could support American conservative beliefs.

I have written elsewhere about the separation of church and state; to me, this should not be a large bone of contention. The point that seems to come up frequently involves the phrase “inalienable rights” in the Declaration of Independence and how it is to be understood.

Natural Law

A key element of the difference has to do with this famous line in the Declaration of Independence: Continue reading

Posted in Theory of Gov't | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Laughing With George Younce – Side By Side

The Cathedrals in 1976 - George Younce far right

(photo credit)

George Younce (1930 – 2005) was a bass vocalist in a Southern Gospel group called The Cathedrals (far right in the above 1976 photo).  He was a very charismatic southern gentleman, with a great Continue reading

Posted in Just Mirth | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment